FINAL REPORT
Saturday February 4, 2006
McLean Community Center
McLean, Virginia
1. Purpose of Teen Summit
2. Planning Committee
3. Funding
4. Topics and Discussions
1) Pre-college and Process Stress
2) Safe Social Alternatives
3) Bullying
4) Alcohol & Drugs
5) Taking Care of Yourself
5. Peer Pressure
6. Evaluation Summary
7. Narratives
8. Comments
Purpose of Teen Summit
The
purpose of the Teen Summit is to provide a forum for discussion, by
students and community leaders, of issues of interest to the students
and to identify opportunities suitable for implementation to address
the issues.
Planning Committee
Students- (Student Connection Coordinators)
Tracey Schulman, Langley High School
Kathleen Clement, Langley High School
David Moody, Langley High School
Esabel Khoury, McLean High School
Helen Li, McLean High School
Adults
Cameron Edgar, Coordinator
Julie White, Food
Bill Regan, Topic Support
Jan Auerbach and Sheri Berman also gave support.
Sharon Burdick and Susan Perla assisted with registration.
Members of the Northern Virginia Junior League helped distribute lunch.
Funding
Funding was provided by the Rotary Club and a Federal Safe and Drug Free Schools and Community Act grant.
Invitations and Attendance
Students
Guidance counselors at McLean High School, Langley High School, Thomas
Jefferson School for Science and Technology and the Potomac School were
requested to provide a list of students to invite. The counselors were
asked to nominate students who represented a good cross-section of the
student body. Langley counselors nominated 22 students. McLean
counselors nominated 38 students. The Potomac school nominated 6
students. No nominations were received from Thomas Jefferson. Each
nominated student received a written invitation. The Student Connection
Coordinators also mailed registration forms to their peers and
classmates.
Besides the five topic student facilitators, seven students registered
for the summit. Of those, six actually attended. In addition, eight
students came who had not registered. A total of 20 students attended
the summit.
Adults
Invitations were mailed to community, educational, and business leaders as follows:
- Langley High School Administrators
- Langley High School PTSA Officers
- McLean High School Administrators
- McLean High School PTSA Officers
- Potomac School Administrators
- Rotary Club
- Chamber of Commerce
- McLean Citizens Association
- Religious Community
- Police Department
- FCPS Officers and School Board
- Dranesville District Supervisor and staff
- McLean Community Center Governing Board
- Teen Center staff
- Safe Community Coalition Board
- Community Leaders and other adults
Of 176 invitation letters mailed, 21adults registered for the summit.
Thirteen adults came who had not registered. A total of 34 adults
attended the summit.
Topics and Discussions
1. Pre-College and Process Stress
Helen Li and Esabel Khoury, Teen Facilitators
Bill Regan and Beth Reisig, Adult Facilitators
1. Standardized tests, administered at younger and younger ages, can
affect student confidence. Taking these tests multiple times makes it
worse. Anxiety is heightened by the TJ placement test. Extracurricular
activities add to stress.
2. Source of stress- parents! They use old models for the college
application process. Parents need to be educated to the realities of
the admissions process. Parents need to realize that a college should
be the best fit for the child, not the most prestigious “prize” for
kids (or parents). The admissions challenge is even greater for
families from other countries who are not familiar with the US system.
3. There is a disconnect between academic expectations, and what
employers actually want. There is the perception that brand-name
colleges are the key to future success, but that does not always pan
out. Students need to use their high school college career centers.
4. Early decision is a source of stress.
5. For some families with economic pressures, there is the additional
pressure of wanting their child to get into elite public universities.
6. Stress starts in Middle School – pressure to get good grades, get into GT programs, honors, etc.
7. In high school the choice is only between regular classes and AP
classes; there is no middle road. There need to be electives that are
challenging but not extreme.
8. Teens want study hall where they can get homework done, and relieve
the pressure on nights and weekends. This desire is in conflict with
the need for more classes to graduate from high school and get into
good colleges.
9. Guidance Counselors are overwhelmed. They have less attention/time
for students. Students then rely on alumni to provide a reality check.
2. Safe Social Alternatives & Understanding Your Place
Kathleen Clement, Teen Facilitator
Joan Morton, Adult Facilitator/Notetaker
- Alcohol
parties are not school wide, but usually involve the same few groups.
They typically are held at homes where parents away.
- Possible
Solutions- Make parents aware of the problem. Suggest, when going away,
that parents ask a neighbor to check periodically or when they see
unusual activity. Let student know this is being done.
- Educate parents about serving alcohol to minors: $500.00 per person fine for serving alcohol to a minor.
- If alcohol/drinking occurs, parents should either require students to sleep over or drive students home.
- If
a student arrives intoxicated or shows signs of drinking when arriving
at a party, parent should require the student to hand over his/her car
keys.
- Parents need to set an example of responsible drinking as well as keep talking with their young people to ensure trust.
- Reason
for alcohol abuse- Students (especially shy students) feel they won’t
have fun if they don’t drink. Also, parents/adults who abuse alcohol at
their parties set a bad example.
Recommendations:
- Encourage tailgate parties before games. Offer free food. Obtain support of a community organization.
- After
games, especially the McLean/Langley football game, hold a “Battle of
the Bands” party at a neutral location such as the McLean Community
Center.
- Advertise (need for better publicity) dry parties and make parents aware of these opportunities.
- A student must be firm in letting friends know he/she will not involve in negative activities.
- Select
friends a student feels comfortable with (someone interested in similar
activities such as sports, drama group, music, etc.)
- Create imaginative activities, i.e., creating videos of your group, fun skits, etc.
- The
McLean Community Center is a good neutral location for teen activities.
It can sponsor events on at least a monthly basis (especially after the
new renovation) or after important school activities such as the
football games. Other suggested ideas are:
- Battle of the Bands
- Movie night with refreshments
- Technology Night
- Teen Care with School Musical groups performing
- Open Mic Night
- The Community Center is the best location in McLean capable of providing a safe environment/place for Teen activities.
- Activities need to be student driven. Encourage students to support student events.
- There
appear to be numerous things to do in McLean or the surrounding
community. The problem seems not to be with the HS students, but with
the MS students as they anticipate attending HS and what their
perception of that is. The group felt that this perception is a result
of what comes out of Hollywood and TV. Both are having a frightenly
negative influence on young people.
- The students feel that there is a need to get to the middle school students before they reach High School.
- Recommend assigning mentors to new/incoming high school students.
- HS students could speak at a MS assembly or to a MS class about what they can expect at HS.
- HS
students could answer questions and hopefully alleviate fears that MS
students have about not being able to measure up or make friends- in
short, what will be expected of them.
3. Bullying in High School?
Tracey Shulman and Shaan Singh, Teen Facilitators
Don Morton, Adult Facilitator/Notetaker
Types of bullying:
- Physical (mostly males)
- Psychological (mostly females)
- Gay supporters are often bullied even though they are not gay.
- Psychological bullying can involve spreading rumors, internet threats, and formations of cliques.
- Bullying is not widespread but, when it occurs, is distracting to the educational experience and can have long-term effects.
- Students do not like bullies, and often tell them so.
- Bullying causes victims not to feel good about themselves.
Recommendations:
- Get kids to talk to kids.
- Write articles in school newspapers.
- Include in Sexual Harassment lectures.
- Encourage vigorous exercise to vent rage.
- Have student leaders discuss.
- Make teachers/coaches/counselors sensitive (not very effective).
4. Alcohol and Drugs
Shaan Singh and Kathleen Clement, Teen Facilitators
Jerry Tankel and Vance Zavela, Adult Facilitator/Notetakers
Discussion on alcohol use
- More and more drinking in junior and senior years, maybe more in freshmen and sophomore years as well.
- Fake
IDs very prevalent—are laminated, can get templates—easy to get them
from seniors and older siblings, although counties and states are
making them more difficult to duplicate.
- Focus
on various sources of alcohol. Kids steal alcohol from their parents;
parents are not keyed to their liquor being so available.
- Seniors appear to be the biggest problem; they make alcohol available to younger partygoers.
- Drinking
is some aspect of rebellion; students are disgusted by those who are
very drunk--that is not considered cool; some students feel obligated
to drink to be “in”.
- Parents take keys away from students coming to a party and then disappear; parent supervision of a party should be a must.
- We are missing the mark; we need to alert all parents to the problem, put more and more responsibility on parents.
- In
the summer at swimming pools teens have booze in coke cans;
opportunities prevail for getting liquor into situations, especially
for late arrivals and older students.
Discussion on drugs
- Drug deals occur right in classes; dealers are in the school and in the area; they are known entities and not strangers.
- Marijuana and prescription drugs like Adderal are the most common drugs.
- Students with legitimate prescriptions for some drugs share the drugs with others.
- Drug education in the schools is not considered effective.
General discussion
- Police have strong awareness at McLean High, not so at Langley; better line of communication at McLean High.
- Some parents are away working and are not in touch with their children for days.
- Even
when not traveling, parents are busy working and are not aware of what
their children are doing; they are in denial that the child could be
doing something illegal.
- Closeness of
family is a positive factor but even some involved parents are naïve as
to what is going on; open relationships with parents are not the norm.
Recommendations
- Educate parents to the problem; sensitize them to what is going on.
- Talk to lower grades, before high school.
- Need effective speakers.
- Safe Prom Week.
- Students know what is going on; staff need to get close to them to learn what is happening and stop the drugs.
5. Taking Care of Yourself (Mental & Physical Health)
Helen Li and Esabel Khoury, Teen Facilitators
Sue King and Eileen Culligan, Adult Facilitator/Notetakers
Discussion:
Eating Disorders –
- Males as well as females affected.
- Athletic weight considerations (wrestling, football, crew).
- Goes down to elementary school level.
- HS
athletic trainers keep track of Body Mass Index (BMI) to
reduce/eliminate weight gain or loss problems; trainers track and
monitor athletes’ injuries to prevent returning to sport too soon.
- Students
confirmed that eating disorders are a problem in school; if they saw
someone purging in a bathroom they might not report it to school staff
but might try to talk with the student.
- Media are a big influence.
- People feel insecure about how they look – suggestion to offer alternatives (even at younger ages) to raise self-esteem.
- Teens need access to programs and information for safe weight loss (nutrition, exercise equipment).
- Name calling based on body shape/weight (either direction – heavy or slim).
- Body image more important to boys now than it was? Body hair.
Mental Health –
- Depression
likely to be reported? Probably not – easy to mask it. Even kids
suffering from it don’t necessarily know they have it.
- Self Mutilation (“cutting”).
- Perception is that “only Goths” do it.
- Happens after school, not at school.
- Not as prevalent as it was a few years ago.
- Sleep Deprivation.
- Affects depression.
- Important for families to discuss.
General Health –
- Health
component of 10th grade PE: focus seems to be more on the dangers of
drugs/alcohol and not so much on basic health and nutrition. School is
losing its authority as the major source of information on diet.
- Health habits start at home but can be changed.
- PE required in 9th and 10th grades (one semester is health in 10th grade); elective in 11th and 12th grades.
- Home life – cultural differences, adult supervision at home overlooking diet, eating habits.
- Parents
can avoid problems when their children are teens by discussing
nutrition and fitness when children are at a young age; should health
get more attention in the elementary curriculum?; why do kids as young
as elementary school start to drink alcohol?
- Kids don’t want others to see health problems.
- Health is not a high priority for teenagers.
- There needs to be more opportunities for exercise outside of sports – boys have more opportunities (pick-up games) than girls.
Recommendations:
- Bring
high school alumni back to schools to talk to kids about eating
disorders, depression, etc. Good times would be after FCPS winter
break, before college students return to school, and in late spring
before HS graduation but after colleges have finished spring semester.
- Continue Wellness Week at high schools.
- Make health classes more interesting and relevant to high school students.
- Organize
focus groups or support groups for various health-related issues – at
McLean classes start at 8:00 on Friday but buses arrive at 7:20 so that
time could be available.
6. Peer Pressure
Tracey Shulman, Teen Facilitator
Sherry Wells, Adult Facilitator/Notetaker
The group discussed positive and negative forms of peer pressure in
high school such as pressure to get good grades, to conform to a
group’s “activity” or image, to drink or have sex, to submit to certain
fashions, or to conform to other social pressures from movies and
Hollywood. They felt there was a good acceptance of persons who were
individuals and wished not to conform and that there was a lot of
freedom for a student to be his/her own person. But the students agreed
that many students felt the need to be accepted and therefore conformed
in some ways; that there was more group pressure than individual
pressure; that there was less pressure in high school than in middle
school, as there were more individual choices or groups to belong to
which allowed you to be the person you wished to be; and that a lot of
pressure such as for good grades was self-imposed. The current drugs in
schools are crack, pot, cigarettes, and ecstasy, but no heroin, or meth.
Strategies for dealing with peer pressure:
- Mentoring of middle school students by high school students to confront the problem of peer pressure before high school.
- Mentoring or befriending new students to give them a friend upon arrival.
- Strict enforcement of rules set by coaches or teams re: drinking and partying.
- Surround yourself with like-minded students to diminish pressure from others.
- School
administrators and student leaders should use positive peer pressure to
encourage obedience to rules, such as no fighting in the school halls
or skipping class.
- Help students develop the self-confidence needed to resist peer pressures.
- Sponsor talks by persons with AIDS to help students resist pressure to have sex.
- Encourage
parents to develop rules and understandings that help students avoid or
be extricated from bad situations such as having agreements that
students can call home anytime and ask to be picked up. Students can
say, “My parents made me come home.”
Evaluation Summary
Evaluation Forms were given to all of those present for the summit. The
forms were compiled and reviewed by Kavita Mittapalli, a George Mason
University graduate student under contract to the Safe Community
Coalition.
14 out of 16 (response rate= 88%) students and 20 out of 29 (response
rate= 69%) adults filled out a one-page feedback form. There was a
combination of open and closed-ended questions regarding the summit in
general and the various sessions in it.
The first section of the feedback form asked questions on the overall
summit including the importance, relevance and impact of the
discussions held, and the location of the summit. Participants circled
Yes or No.
Results indicate that the topics covered at the summit were considered
important and relevant by all the participants. They rated it the
highest (sum=33, mean=1.00, sd=0.000), followed by the location of the
summit (sum=31, mean=.94, sd=0.242). Table 1 illustrates the results.
Table 1
|
Topic
|
NUMBER of “YES” ANSWERS
|
MEAN
|
STANDARD DEVIATION (sd)
|
|
Did the
discussion provide you new insights on these issues?
|
|
.85
|
.364
|
|
Were the
discussion topics important and relevant?
|
33
|
1.00
|
.000
|
|
Do you
think positive changes can be made to address these issues?
|
28
|
.90
|
.301
|
|
Was the
Community Center a good location for this event?
|
31
|
.94
|
.242
|
Table
2 presents the results for various aspects of the summit. Participants
circled Excellent, Good, Average or Poor. Results are in percentages.
Table 2&
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
32
|
55
|
10
|
3
|
|
|
58
|
39
|
3
|
|
|
|
56
|
38
|
6
|
|
|
Lunch/Refreshments
|
62
|
35
|
3
|
|
|
Facility
|
74
|
24
|
3
|
|
* Percentages have been rounded to the nearest second decimal.
22 out of 34 (65%) participants expressed their willingness to be a part of the follow-up meetings on the topics discussed.
Narratives
Participants were asked to list the topics they would like to be
discussed at future summits. They listed parental responsibility,
internet blogging, sex, time management, self-image, additional
information on pre-college stress, parent-student communication, media,
eating disorders, drinking and drugs and gangs.
Participants were asked to comment on aspect of the summit they would
like changed. A larger representation of teen students for summits like
this was the most recurring comment made by both student and
adult participants, followed by providing more time for discussions, an
opportunity to sit through other sessions and a need for breakout rooms
for sessions.
All the comments are included below-
|
It would
have been better if each situation were 'isolated' in
separate room.
|
|
During
the week. Need more students and fewer adults.
|
|
Not all
sessions were held in the same room, I couldn't hear the
others.
|
|
Love the
school model. Maybe it could be done earlier in the school
year?
|
|
Need to
involve more students (6)
|
|
The
summit needs to be pushed harder by the school administrator
and student leaders.
|
|
More
students, fewer adults. Adults intervened for others,
typically with an agenda many were not listening or were not
open-minded.
|
|
Need
breakout rooms for sessions. The room was too noisy.
|
|
Attendance by teens needs to be better. Consider having a
program during normal school hours.
|
|
Hold
during school day to attract more students.
|
|
Rather
than focusing totally on what's going on, focus on how to
change these things.
|
|
I would
like to take part in more topics.
|
|
Need a
bigger student voice.
|
|
I would
like to see more teenagers from various groups- possible
drug users, athletes, leaders, etc.
|
|
More
balanced groups in terms of mentors.
|
|
If we
could have shorter summits so we could talk about the topics
more.
|
|
Veggies
for lunch. I liked it…thanks!
|
|
More
time for discussion (3).
|
Finally,
participants were asked if they wanted any strategies developed based
on the summit’s discussion groups. The responses included having
pre-training sessions, involving school counselors, administrators and
police in topics related to youth, holding a summit for younger
children, pushing harder for solutions rather than just discussions,
and discussing issues of bullying.
All comments are included below-
|
Are
there or could there be classes or sessions to address these
alcohol and drug problems in the schools? Faculty and police
should be involved.
|
|
Larger
groups. Need to have more topics to discuss. Closer work
with the school counselor and nurse.
|
|
Hold a
summit for younger children.
|
|
Push
harder for solutions and not just discussions.
|
|
Having
this during the school day.
|
|
Look
into activities at MCC, which will bring in more teens.
Develop better communication between parents and kids to
establish more trust.
|
|
Have SCC
take a lead to address bullying.
|
|
Kids
getting to other kids, parents being more approachable.
|
|
More
pre-college groups.
|
|
For
alcohol- an education of moderation is very important
because even if you try to prevent the spread of alcohol,
kids will find a way to get it.
|
|
Perhaps
a training session beforehand.
|
|
I think
parents and counselors should talk about pre-college stress.
They should tell us that it's okay to take regular courses
and not AP!
|
|
Kids
helping their peers/parents becoming more involved.
|
|
Place
where kids can hang out with some music and videogames.
|
|
I think
it needs to be managed better. I put my form in the box at
school, and didn't hear about anything beyond that. I didn't
know about the time of the summit, what to expect and what
to wear.
|
|
A
bowling alley should be in McLean. Parents should know where
their kids are and they should enforce healthy eating
habits.
|
|
Parent-child relationships.
|
|
High
school students spending a day with middle school students.
|
|